You are here: News & Events >> Mini Tutorials >> MFA vs Other Control Methods Comparison
 
     
 
 Announcements
 Magazine Articles
 Trade Shows
 MFA Books
   • Process Software and    Digital Networks
   • MFA in Control with    CyboCon
   • Techniques for Adaptive    Control
   • Process Control and    Optimization
 Training
 Mini Tutorials
   • Model-Free Adaptive    (MFA) Control
   • PID Control and MFA vs    PID Comparison
   • Advanced Control    Methods Overview
   • MFA vs Other Control    Methods Comparison
 
MFA vs Other Control Methods Comparison

The following table provides a comparison of PID, Model Predictive Control (MPC), Robust control design method, Model-based Adaptive control, and Model-Free Adaptive (MFA) control. It can be concluded that MFA combines the merits of all of these control methods and is the best candidate to be the next generation of mainstream process controller.

Comparison of Control Methods

Compared Item PID Model Predictive Robust Control Model-based Adaptive Model-Free Adaptive
General Purpose Y N N N Y
Adaptive Capability N N N Y Y
No process model Y N N N Y
No identification Y Y Y N Y
No controller design Y N N N Y
No controller manual tuning N Y Y Y Y
Stability criteria available Y Y/N Y Y/N Y
Easy to use and maintain N N N N Y
Candidate for next generation mainstream controller N N N N Y
 
     
  © 2014 CyboSoft, General Cybernation Group, Inc.
Home | Search | Site Map | Legal | Contact Us